How to Respond to Peer Review Comments: An Engineering Author’s Workflow

Quick answer: A strong peer-review response is a traceable engineering document. Copy every reviewer comment into a response matrix, classify the requested action, revise the manuscript, cite the exact changed location and explain respectfully when a suggestion cannot be adopted. Never answer from memory or hide a partial change behind a general statement.

Why engineering responses fail
Technical papers often combine equations, experiments, software, drawings and assumptions. One apparently small reviewer request may affect several sections. Changing a control parameter in Methods without updating the Results table, uncertainty analysis and conclusion creates a new inconsistency. The response letter therefore needs the same configuration discipline as an engineering change record.
Build a response matrix first
Create one row for every editor and reviewer comment. Use columns for identifier, issue type, required evidence, manuscript action, response text, page and line location, and verification status. Keep the reviewer’s wording intact so nothing is lost.
| Class | Typical request | Evidence to prepare |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Clarify novelty or limits | Revised objective and boundary statement |
| Method | Justify a model or test | Equation, standard, calibration or sensitivity check |
| Results | Add comparison or uncertainty | Recalculation, plot and updated data table |
| Presentation | Improve figure or terminology | Revised graphic, caption and consistent symbols |
| Interpretation | Reduce an unsupported claim | Qualified wording linked to evidence |
Write each point-by-point answer
- Acknowledge the issue. State what the reviewer noticed without defensiveness.
- State the action. Say exactly what was changed, added, recalculated or removed.
- Show the evidence. Give the key result or rationale, not only “done.”
- Locate the revision. Cite the revised section and current page/line numbers.
- Check propagation. Update abstract, tables, nomenclature, conclusions and supplementary files when the same fact appears there.
How to disagree professionally
Agreement is not mandatory, but evidence is. Explain the governing constraint, show the relevant calculation or source, and offer a clarifying revision. A useful pattern is: “We agree that X requires clarification. We did not apply Y because it would violate assumption Z; instead, we added a sensitivity analysis and stated the limitation in Section 4.3.” Avoid claims about the reviewer’s competence or intentions.
Engineering verification checklist
- Re-run scripts and preserve the exact software version and inputs.
- Check units, significant figures, uncertainty and axis labels.
- Confirm every cited table and figure exists after renumbering.
- Search the manuscript for superseded values and terminology.
- Make sure the clean manuscript and marked manuscript contain the same technical content.
- Verify that confidential or identifying information is handled according to the journal’s review model.
Mini example
Comment: “Please justify the selected 15-minute sampling interval.” Weak answer: “The text was updated.” Better answer: “We added the sensor logging limit and repeated the energy calculation at 5, 15 and 30 minutes. Annual yield changed by 0.3% between 5 and 15 minutes but by 2.1% at 30 minutes. Section 2.4 and Table 3 now report this sensitivity and identify 15 minutes as the operational compromise.”
FAQ
Should every comment receive a separate answer?
Yes. Even when two comments lead to one revision, answer each identifier and cross-reference the shared change.
Should the response letter repeat the full revised paragraph?
Quote only the portion needed to verify the change, then give page and line numbers. Follow the journal’s instructions.
Can new experiments be declined?
Yes, when the request is outside scope or infeasible, but explain the technical reason and strengthen the limitation statement or analysis where possible.
Related guides
- Engineering lab report structure and uncertainty
- Engineering literature review workflow
- Engineering journal selection checklist
Authoritative references
Always follow the target journal’s current author instructions; they override generic formatting advice.



